The Age of Accountability and God's wrath

Man, Sin, & Salvation
Post Reply
User avatar
Homer
Posts: 2995
Joined: Sat Aug 23, 2008 11:08 pm

The Age of Accountability and God's wrath

Post by Homer » Tue Nov 03, 2009 1:35 am

Hi Steve,

You made the following statement on the thread about hell:
When you say that a person under wrath should not expect undeserved grace, I have to ask what condition you and I were in before we came to Christ? Were we not "children of wrath, even as others"?
As I understand your personal testimony, you became a Christian in your youth, seemingly while having not yet reached the age of accountability. So how could you personally have ever been a "child of wrath"?

I think you and I both share a belief that we are not guilty of Adam's sin, nor any of our own until we reach an age of accountability. Rather than using you as an example, let me use my late sister. She was a good kid, and very much a follower of Christ - a good example of what it means to be a Christian. At the age of twelve, she was baptized into Christ, and was faithful unto death. I would certainly consider a twelve year old as having not reached the age of accountability. Could she have ever been "a child of wrath" or does the "age of accountabily" theory have holes in it?

Blessings, Homer

User avatar
Mellontes
Posts: 465
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2008 12:50 pm
Location: Canada

Re: The Age of Accountability and God's wrath

Post by Mellontes » Thu Nov 19, 2009 10:45 am

Homer wrote:Hi Steve,

You made the following statement on the thread about hell:
When you say that a person under wrath should not expect undeserved grace, I have to ask what condition you and I were in before we came to Christ? Were we not "children of wrath, even as others"?
As I understand your personal testimony, you became a Christian in your youth, seemingly while having not yet reached the age of accountability. So how could you personally have ever been a "child of wrath"?

I think you and I both share a belief that we are not guilty of Adam's sin, nor any of our own until we reach an age of accountability. Rather than using you as an example, let me use my late sister. She was a good kid, and very much a follower of Christ - a good example of what it means to be a Christian. At the age of twelve, she was baptized into Christ, and was faithful unto death. I would certainly consider a twelve year old as having not reached the age of accountability. Could she have ever been "a child of wrath" or does the "age of accountability" theory have holes in it?

Blessings, Homer
Although not completely relevant, this age of accountability does have implications for the Gospel being spread to all the "world" before the "end" comes.
Here is an excerpt from my book "Creeds, Credentials, or Christ?"

"Many Christian evangelical conservatives believe that one day the Gospel will finally be preached to all individuals on this planet, and when the very last person is ministered to, it will usher in their whole “end times” scenario. However, with one child being born every second, resulting in over 100 million births every year, how does this view expect to overcome this obstacle? Added to that, some theologies believe that the individual must grow to an unknown (preschool?) age in order to comprehend the Gospel – all the while adding hundreds of millions more which must also wait to grow to that undetermined age! The “last” person is an absolute impossibility because there is always at least three years of newborn activity prior to presenting the Gospel to the individual who has just grown to that “age of accountability.” Not all facets of Christianity hold to this “age of accountability,” but it is considered by many to be the majority dispensational stance."

User avatar
steve
Posts: 3392
Joined: Thu Aug 21, 2008 9:45 pm

Re: The Age of Accountability and God's wrath

Post by steve » Thu Nov 19, 2009 11:46 am

Hi Homer,

Sorry about you getting cut off in the middle of our conversation yesterday on the air. Maybe we can finish the conversation today, if the equipment will cooperate (I think it is the lousy internet service here in Kona).

You wrote:
As I understand your personal testimony, you became a Christian in your youth, seemingly while having not yet reached the age of accountability. So how could you personally have ever been a "child of wrath"?

I think you and I both share a belief that we are not guilty of Adam's sin, nor any of our own until we reach an age of accountability. Rather than using you as an example, let me use my late sister. She was a good kid, and very much a follower of Christ - a good example of what it means to be a Christian. At the age of twelve, she was baptized into Christ, and was faithful unto death. I would certainly consider a twelve year old as having not reached the age of accountability. Could she have ever been "a child of wrath" or does the "age of accountabily" theory have holes in it?
I agree with you about this. I believe there is an age of accountability, and that before that age is reached, one is not under God's wrath. When Paul told the Ephesians that they (and he) had formerly been "children of wrath," he was obviously considering primarily adult converts, like himself and the heathen Ephesians.

When I say "we (even when I say "you and I") were children of wrath," I am speaking generically about Christians before conversion—without suggesting that all of us were actually recipients of wrath, since many have been Christians from a young age. Peter used "we" and "our past lifetime" this way with his readers, in speaking about formerly "doing the will of the Gentiles—when we walked in...abominable idolatries"(1 Peter 4:3). As a Jew, I am sure that he had never lived in the Gentile manner, and had never participated in idolatry, but most of his readers had, so he included himself editorially. I usually speak the same way.

In fact, I am not sure that my conversion in childhood was genuine. There were evidences of genuine spiritual concern thereafter, but I would still be willing to listen to an argument that I was not reborn until age 16, when I was baptized in the Holy Spirit. However, looking back, I truly did trust Christ prior to that—at least to the degree that He had been presented to me—so God only knows. I feel safe in speculating that I could have been less-than-saved in some of the adolescent years prior to age 16, but I cannot say. It just seems reasonable (and perhaps more modest) to include myself with others in statements about former pre-Christian conditions. I may not technically have been a "child of wrath," but I certainly had some motives, attitudes and behaviors that were displeasing to God, and not worthy of being called Christian.

Post Reply

Return to “Anthropology, Hamartiology, Soteriology”